| Name | Location 1 | Location 2 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plummer, Hannah | 15 | name scratched out in WCHS copy | |
| Plummer, Peter | 15 | name scratched out in WCHS copy | |
| Powell, Mrs. | 16 | handwritten into WCHS copy: "Mrs. Powell" | |
| Prince, Carrie E | 16 | ||
| Prince, Emily S | 16 | ||
| Prince, H B | 14 | listed under Elders, 4 years | |
| Prince, H B | 14 | listed under Trustees | |
| Prince, Henry B | 16 | ||
| Reiner, Eliza C | 14 | name handwritten into WCHS copy | |
| Rhodes, Esther H | 15 | ||
| Rhodes, Francis E | 15 | ||
| Rice, Amanda M | 15 | ||
| Rice, Herman | 15 | ||
| Robinson, Elizabeth | 16 | ||
| Roney, Clarissa | 15 | ||
| Roney, Mary A | 15 | ||
| Rood, Sarah N | 15 | ||
| Sabin, D M | 14 | listed under Trustees | |
| Seward, Elizabeth | 16 | ||
| Seward, Virgil B | 16 | handwritten into WCHS copy: "Virgil B. Seward" | |
| Seward, Wm. H | 16 | ||
| Seymour, Geo. M | 14 | listed under Trustees | |
| Seymour, Hannah | 15 | ||
| Seymour, M Oretha | 15 | ||
| Shepard, Myron | 14 | listed under Trustees | |
| Sinclair, Eliza | 14 | ||
| Sinclair, James | 14 | listed under Trustees; Treasuer | |
| Sinclair, Susanna | 16 | ||
| Smith, Lilla A | 16 | handwritten into WCHS copy: "Lilla A. Smith" | |
| Smithson, Wm. | 16 | handwritten into WCHS copy: "Wm. Smithson" | |
| Spencer, Rose | 16 | ||
| Staples, Isaac | 14 | listed under Trustees | |
| Staples, Oliva J | 15 | ||
| Stein, Abba W | 15 | ||
| Stewart, William | 15 | name marked with a handwritten asterisk (*) and the notation "Died" in WCHS copy | |
| Swain, Caroline E | 15 | ||
| Taylor, Sarah | 14 | ||
| Thorne, Olive A B | 15 | ||
| Tozer, David | 14 | listed under Trustees | |
| Underwood, Mary D | 16 | ||
| Van Vorhes, Abram | 14 | ||
| Waldron, Josephine | 16 | ||
| Waldron, Mary D | 16 | ||
| White, Anna | 16 | ||
| White, Mary W | 16 | ||
| Young, Mrs. Capt. | 15 | handwritten into WCHS copy: "Mrs. Capt Young" |